TABLE OF CONTENTS
Section A: Myths and assumptions…………………………………………………………………
A-1. Myths about the value of creating mentoring
relationships
A-2. Myths about the design of mentoring programs
Section B: Missing elements in the mentoring process—knowledge
and skills that mentors need
B-1. Equipping and urging mentors to discuss eight
typical stresses for early-stage faculty
B-2. Equipping and urging
mentors to discuss additional stresses experienced by faculty mentees in certain groups and situations
♦
Gender bias against women, especially in science and engineering
♦
Group bias, especially against African Americans, American Indians, Puerto Rican Americans, Mexican Americans,
and Native Hawaiians
♦
“Solo situation” in a department
♦
How mentors can help their mentees deal with negative bias and the solo phenomenon
B-3. Enhancing the quality of the mentoring relationship:
pointers for mentors and mentees
♦
Frontloading—begin early
♦
Ask about hurtful or confusing “critical incidents”
♦
Disclosure by the mentor can build trust
♦
When arguing, use “I” messages
♦
Giving and receiving constructive feedback
Section C: Missing elements in the design of
formal mentoring programs
C-1. Experimenting with various
modes (transitional mentor; informal or formal mentor; internal or external mentor; project-oriented mentor; group mentoring;
mentoring network; writing and peer- support groups; zone mentors; search committee evolves into mentoring committee)
C-2. Readiness workshops
for mentors and then for mentees: Eight key elements of content and process. Two
practice “discussion scenarios” for use in workshops at D-3
C-3. Dovetailing
a mentoring program with existing professional-development efforts
C-4. Gauging
the effectiveness of mentor-mentee relationships and overall mentoring programs
♦
Securing systematic feedback to help mentors and mentees stay on course
♦
Outcomes evaluation: consistently document mentoring program outcomes
C-5. UCSD
medical school’s exemplary program of mentoring and professional-development
Section
D: Supplementary materials
D-1 For Mentors and Mentees
♦
Benefits of mentoring for mentees, mentors, and their institutions: Summary
♦
Providing social-psychological and career support: Illustrations
♦
Dysfunctional behaviors of mentors and mentees: Illustrations
♦
Commencing the relationship: Tips; Checklist for first meeting
D-2. For Provosts, Deans, & Department
Chairs
♦
Checklist for sustaining a mentoring climate and mentoring programs
♦
Checklist for chairs: serving as faculty developers, especially for new hires
D-3. For Organizers & Evaluators of
Formal Mentoring Programs
♦
Checklist for building and evaluating a formal mentoring program
♦
Discussion Scenarios—use in orientations and workshops for mentors, mentees,
chairs, deans, early-stage faculty, etc.